Let’s talk audiobooks!

This is an ongoing discussion in the book community and no one can seem to decide! Opinions seem to be strongly yes, or strongly no, but rarely in between. So I ask you this question:

Do you think that audiobooks count as a book read towards your Goodreads reading goal?

I, for some strange reason, am obsessed with this discussion. I can understand the reasoning behind each of the sides, but I am very much on the side that believes that YES they count. Some people say that because the person is not physically reading the book it doesn’t count. Others say that you can’t possibly multitask while reading a physical book, so the fact that you can do other things while “reading” makes it void. Some even say – “It’s cheating.” That having the book read to you means you technically didn’t read the book so it’s not possible to count it as a book “read.”

Yes, these are valid points, and I do understand how someone could feel this way. And it’s not my goal to change your mind or tell you that you’re wrong for thinking this way! Everyone is entitled to their opinion and if you don’t believe they count it then that’s fine. My goal with this post is to share my opinion and hear the thoughts of others, even if they don’t agree with me! Discussions are what make you see things in a different light and I love that about the blogging community!

Arrow

REASONS WHY I THINK AUDIOBOOKS COUNT

  • Even though I may not have the physical book in hand, I am still getting every single word out of the story. It may not be the voice inside my head that I’m hearing, but at least I am able to listen to the words the author wrote. I look at “read” books on Goodreads as a form of consumption. I’m still consuming the book, just in a different way.
  • A good point made from the “no” side of camp is that you go through a book faster when you listen to it opposed to reading it physically. This may be the case for some, but it actually takes me longer (MUCH longer sometimes) to make it through an audiobook opposed to reading. Some audiobooks can be well over 10 hours in length but it would take me close to half the time if I was reading it physically. So in reality I actually read less when I’m listening to a book.
  • This point kind of goes with the first one – regardless of how I’m consuming the book, I’m still spending time on it and that should count as something, right?

Arrow

WHY I LIKE AUDIOBOOKS

Though I may be on “Camp-yes-they-count” now, I used to be on Camp No. My own opinions of audiobooks didn’t change until last summer. I used to HATE them and felt that it wasn’t really reading unless you held the book. But a friend of mine last summer suggested that I listen to a particular book because she really loved the way it was narrated. I had tried to listen to audiobooks so many times before but it annoyed me and I couldn’t get attached to the the readers voice. I don’t remember what book it was but it changed the game for me. I work from home and spend hours sitting at a table packaging our products, not needing to talk to anyone. I’m not much for TV so it’s the perfect opportunity for me to work and listen to a book. Now I feel like I’m keeping up with my reading while also being more productive! I used to think that listening opposed to reading took away from the experience, but now that I’ve gotten used to it, I actually quite enjoy it! So if you don’t like audiobooks now – keep trying!

Arrow

HOW I LISTEN TO AUDIOBOOKS

Oh how I love the Overdrive app! I found out about it through my local library and I am forever grateful that the librarian gave me the info! If your library is a part of this then I highly suggest to check it out!

Overdrive

Once you download the app, you use your library card to sign in. Both audiobooks and ebooks are available and you check them out just as you would a library book. Even though they are digital files, they are not unlimited, so there is still a chance that the title won’t be available immediately, but placing holds is really easy! The great thing about placing holds is that it will download automatically, notify you when it’s ready, and even tell you how many people are ahead of you in the line. But what sold me about this app is that you can download the files to your phone so if you’re out you don’t need Wi-Fi and it won’t use your data! You also don’t have to worry about returning the files as it does it automatically. You can return early once you’re done though. This app also gives you great search options! You can search for a specific author or book, ebooks or audiobooks specifically, as well as titles that are available immediately if you don’t want to wait.

Arrow

Do you listen to audiobooks? Do you have a favourite? How do you listen to them? Always the curious reader 🙂

Until next time, happy reading!

37 Comments Add yours

  1. Great discussion post 😁 I need to listen to more audiobooks as they are a great way to change the whole dynamic of enjoying a book. I would definitely say they count as they are still a book, just reformatted for convenience.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. MaddieM says:

    I definitely think they count! I mean, they are books aren’t they 😉 I just recently fell in love with audiobooks, but still there are some books I prefer to read rather than listen to, non-fiction and classics for example. Also I found that the narrator can make or break the audiobook. I recently listened to Why the Caged Bird Sings on Audiobook and Maya Angelou’s voice put me to sleep almost every time I listened, so I had to listen to it in short doses. Neil Gaiman is my favorite narrator, he brings even more life into it already lively books! Great post, it’s always a fun discussion!

    Liked by 3 people

    1. OH! Now that you mention it… the book that got me into audiobooks was The Ocean at the End of the Lane by Neil Gaiman! How did I forget that! His voice was great! You’re right though – a voice makes or breaks it. Especially when they change their voice for each character and it just sounds annoying and unnatural.

      Liked by 2 people

  3. Yes, they count for me! I have a friend who is on the No Camp and he basically says the same stuff: that people are cheating when they’re listening to an audiobook, etc. I think that’s pretty petty… Who cares how you read a story? It’s not like it’s a competition LOL
    Plus, our parents used to read us stories and did anyone ever complain they hadn’t really “read” a book because it had been read to them, instead? No. So I think it’s no different.
    Besides, shouldn’t anything that helps people read more be considered a positive thing? Why are we making it a problem?
    Anyway, great post Shanah!

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Thanks! It shouldn’t matter how you read a story, but the fact that you’ve now got that story in your memory bank! It’s so funny how it’s either yes, no, and no in-between lol

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Hahaha that’s true! I hadn’t realized that XD

        Liked by 1 person

  4. mikaela says:

    Yes, I love Overdrive! It was such an amazing discovery! I personally don’t listen to audiobooks because I’m just not a person who can pay attention to people just talking, but they definitely should count towards a Goodreads goal!

    Liked by 3 people

  5. If audiobooks don’t count, then nothing your parents’ read to you as a child counts either… Of course audiobooks count! It’s a way to keep reading AND actually get housework done (or enjoy a long drive, or whatever)!

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Exactly!! I wonder who you’ll choose to narrate YOUR audiobook when it gets published? 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. You’re so good for my ego… LOL!

        Liked by 1 person

      2. And it kills me that I can’t take fix that apostrophe. It should not be there…. Why did I put one there? Typing too fast and my brain doesn’t work…

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Oh my. I should stop commenting today. I clearly can’t communicate well. *hangs head in shame*

          Liked by 1 person

        2. You are a true writer! LOL

          Like

  6. Justine says:

    Audiobooks absolutely count, but I admit I was once in the ‘IT’S NOT REALLY READING SO IT DOESN’T COUNT’ camp too. My mind was changed when I started walking to and from my old job. I had about an hour each way and I felt like that was just wasted time that was waiting to be filled. I discovered audiobooks — or to be more exact, biographies via audiobook — on Scribd. I struggle with biography and some nonfiction, but audiobooks are the perfect format for me an that site, if it’s still even running, had loads of them. I need to start listening again because it really was a great way to take in these kinds of books!

    Liked by 3 people

    1. I also struggle with non fiction type audiobooks. Though Furiously Happy was one of the greatest audiobook experiences EVER! I usually go in spurts listening to them and then take a lot of time off. Then I can come back to them refreshed

      Liked by 2 people

  7. Great discussion post! I respect that many people like audiobooks, however I’m personally not a fan of them but I do think they count! I mostly dislike them because I’m a terrible auditory learner and really won’t pick up on anything if I listen to one. I also like reading at my own pace and being able to rush ahead, whereas I feel like you miss out on that when listening to an audiobook.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. That’s very true – you can’t choose your pace with an audiobook. I’m constantly stopping or pausing because I get distracted and know I won’t retain anything!

      Liked by 1 person

  8. YES THEY SHOULD COUNT. I’ve read books and then listened to the audio book version. Completely different expience but same book. Some people with vision problems or time constraints have no choice. These are STILL books. How you absorb them is irrelevant.

    Liked by 3 people

  9. I’m totally on the side of YES audiobooks do count. Whether a person heard it or read it with their own eyes, they still know the story. And like, what if someone has poor eyesight? It’s funny how these things get competitive when usually all we’re looking for is to be entertained. There are books I’ve read and listened to just because I love them so much and it’s fun to experience them different ways. And like you said, it usually takes me WAY longer to finish audiobooks than physically reading them. I think it’s mainly because I don’t listen to audiobooks for more than an hour or two at a time, and it’s usually while I’m doing something else. So finishing an audiobook is a different kind of satisfying than physically closing a book cover! And to be honest I usually turn to audiobooks when I have difficulty reading a book or concentrating on it- so many classics I’ve read I have actually listened to. Certain kinds of dialogue, like in older books from the 1700s or 1800s, I understand so much better when I hear it, like the narrator gives it the emotion and context I can’t perceive from the page, kind of like seeing a play versus reading it.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. I’ve never tried listening to a classic in audiobook form. But you’re right. Books that are written a while ago are sometimes difficult to follow and understand when you’re reading them. But if you listen to someone read it out loud it seems to all of a sudden make sense.
      And you also make a good point about those with vision problems. I’m sure that it would be considered a book read if they listened to an audiobook so why doesn’t it count for those who have no problems with eye sight? Like you said – it’s not a competition!

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Lol I’ve actually listened to like 3 Charles Dickens books via audiobooks…I love his novels but they’re so dense to read physically. And of course they’re all like 20 hours long so it takes me weeks to get through them, but they’re pleasant to listen to when I’m working on things that might not need too much brain power at work!

        Liked by 1 person

  10. Hello Bionic Book Worm 😀 I am nominating you to participate in the Blogger Stats Book Tag: https://alwaystrustinbooks.wordpress.com/2017/04/21/blogger-stats-book-tag-bookreviewedition/

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks so much for thinking of me! I’m not sure when I’ll get around to this though. I’ve got so much planned for the next few weeks

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I understand, tis just a bit of fun 😀 I have crafted the questions so they don’t take up to much of your time. There will be plenty more tags coming your way I’m afraid so pick and choose which you fancy doing!

        Liked by 1 person

  11. I really love audiobooks, they are usually my main source of reading. I actually prefer listening to books then reading them by myself. It actually quite annoys me when people say it’s “cheating”, I understand the opposing argument but I am strongly pro audiobooks.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. The word cheating annoys me to no end! I think that word is really unfair when it comes to audiobooks!

      Liked by 2 people

  12. The Other Weasley says:

    Yes they count. Audiobooks have helped me get into books that I had trouble connected by to. I would have missed one of my current favorites if not for the audiobook. I also love using them for re reads. I catch different information in an audiobook and it enhances my reading experience.
    I have found ones I don’t like but audiobooks make my commute bearable and I will continue to count them!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Out of curiosity, what audiobook was one of your favourites? I’m always looking for new and good ones 🙂
      Also I completely agree that they’re a great way to do a reread. You already know the story so it doesn’t matter if you catch literally every word.

      Like

  13. Yes! I LOVE audiobooks! Also, there is a lot of scientific research supporting the fact that audiobooks have the same effects not he brain that actually reading a book does. It’s all about absorbing yourself in a story and taking that in.

    Liked by 2 people

  14. da AL says:

    great subject! apparently everyone here thinks they count – cuz I do too! am addicted to them – I listen to books on cd in my car – also on boombox which is either on ‘play’ or ‘pause’ all day. I listen as I brush my teeth, wash dishes, eat lunch, cook, clean, etc

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I wish I could listen to audiobooks all day! But when my kids are yelling “mom” every two seconds, it gets distracting lol.

      Liked by 1 person

  15. I’m actually on Camp-In-Between 😛 My take is that it depends on the individual’s intentions, as in, whether they set their reading goals to know the stories/content or to improve their reading part of the brain.

    Great topic for discussion, might I say! Would love to see more of these 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s a really good point! I agree with you. If someone is listening to an audiobook just to increase stats then it’s not really fair. Obviously as an avid reader I set goals for myself, but I set them low because stats aren’t my endgame. In the long run I’m reading to hear the story and learn new things – so stats don’t really matter. Great point! Thanks for sharing

      Liked by 1 person

  16. Oh, and I used to listen to podcasts while doing the dishes or crocheting, so I know what you mean! It’s a great way to make full use of your time.

    Liked by 1 person

  17. Marta says:

    My local library would never have anything like that, but the idea is very good! I’ve never tried a full audiobook, I just really can’t concentrate 😦 But I do believe they count towards the Goodreads goal – you’re still learning about a story, so why not?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment